Case Number #721

Clauses: Clause 1 (Accuracy and Clarity)

Concerns: Unsupported Performance Claim

Advertiser: Automotive Appraiser

Region: Ontario

Industry: Automotive

Media Type: Advertiser Website

Number of Complaints: 1

Year: 2026

Description:

On the homepage of the advertiser’s website, a #1 consumer preference claim was prominently made.

Complaint:

The complainant challenged the accuracy of the claim.

Response:

In its response to Council, the advertiser advised that they do not have independent, verifiable data to substantiate the claim and revised the claim on their website to not claim superiority in the marketplace.

Decision:

Council appreciated the advertiser’s response and considered the complaint together with the advertiser’s submissions.

Given the advertiser’s acknowledgement that they did not have support to substantiate the superiority claim, Council members found that the claim was a misrepresentation of the truth that resulted in an advertisement that was misleading. One Council member added that the claim was, “a representation meant to induce a certain feeling from customers…based on their own internal views of themselves…this is a clear violation…”

Council unanimously held that the advertisement contained an inaccurate, deceptive or otherwise misleading claim which was not supported by competent and reliable evidence in contravention with Clause 1(a) and 1(e) of the Code.

Infraction:

Clause 1(a), Clause 1(e)

Scroll to top